EduKG
← Back

Visualizing superposition and standing waves

Learning objectives

  • Outcome

    Calculate the resultant displacement of two counter-propagating waves at a given point and time by applying the superposition principle.

  • Outcome

    Determine the node and antinode positions of a standing wave from the known wavelength and boundary conditions.

  • Outcome

    Compute the natural frequencies of a string fixed at both ends and state which quantities Melde's and Kundt's experiments measured.

Understand the idea

Visualizing Superposition and Standing Waves: A Practice with History and Calculations

Text

The superposition principle states that the displacement of the medium at every point equals the sum of the displacements that each wave would produce alone. If two waves of equal frequency and amplitude travel toward each other, their sum carries no energy along the axis and forms a standing wave y(x,t)=2Asin⁡(kx)cos⁡(ωt)y(x,t)=2A\sin(kx)\cos(\omega t). Points where sin⁡(kx)=0\sin(kx)=0 never move at all — these are nodes, and the distance between neighbouring nodes is λ/2\lambda/2. Points where ∣sin⁡(kx)∣=1|\sin(kx)|=1 oscillate with the maximum amplitude 2A2A — these are antinodes. The boundaries set the spectrum of natural frequencies: for a string fixed at both ends, L=nλ/2L=n\lambda/2 and fn=nv2Lf_n=\dfrac{nv}{2L}. Exactly such patterns were studied by Chladni (figures on plates, 1787), Melde (a vibrating string, 1859) and Kundt (dust in a tube, 1866).

Worked examples

Direct

Problem

Two waves of equal amplitude A=0.020A=0.020 m and wavelength λ=0.80\lambda=0.80 m travel toward each other: y1=Asin⁡(kx−ωt)y_1=A\sin(kx-\omega t) and y2=Asin⁡(kx+ωt)y_2=A\sin(kx+\omega t). Find the displacement at x=0.30x=0.30 m at time t=0t=0 and decide whether this point is a node or an antinode.

Solution

Add the waves using the superposition principle:

y=y1+y2=2Asin⁡(kx)cos⁡(ωt).y=y_1+y_2=2A\sin(kx)\cos(\omega t).

The wave number:

k=2πλ=2π0.80=7.854 m−1.k=\frac{2\pi}{\lambda}=\frac{2\pi}{0.80}=7.854\ \text{m}^{-1}.

At x=0.30x=0.30 m: kx=7.854⋅0.30=2.356kx=7.854\cdot0.30=2.356 rad, sin⁡(kx)=0.707\sin(kx)=0.707.

At t=0t=0, cos⁡(ωt)=1\cos(\omega t)=1, so

y=2⋅0.020⋅0.707=0.028 m.y=2\cdot0.020\cdot0.707=0.028\ \text{m}.

Nodes occur where sin⁡(kx)=0\sin(kx)=0, i.e. x=mλ/2=0.40mx=m\lambda/2=0.40m m: x=0x=0, 0.400.40, 0.800.80 m. Antinodes occur at x=(2m+1)λ/4x=(2m+1)\lambda/4: 0.200.20, 0.600.60 m. Thus x=0.30x=0.30 m is neither a node nor an antinode; the oscillation amplitude there is 2A∣sin⁡(kx)∣=0.0282A|\sin(kx)|=0.028 m.

Application

Problem

In Kundt's experiment, dust in a glass tube of air forms heaps; the distance between neighbouring heaps is 0.1700.170 m. The speed of sound in air is v=340v=340 m/s and the tube length is L=0.510L=0.510 m. Find the wavelength, the frequency and the harmonic number.

Solution

The dust heaps collect at the nodes of the standing wave, and neighbouring nodes are λ/2\lambda/2 apart:

λ=2⋅0.170=0.340 m.\lambda=2\cdot0.170=0.340\ \text{m}.

The frequency:

f=vλ=3400.340=1000 Hz.f=\frac{v}{\lambda}=\frac{340}{0.340}=1000\ \text{Hz}.

The boundary condition L=nλ/2L=n\lambda/2 gives

n=2Lλ=2⋅0.5100.340=3,n=\frac{2L}{\lambda}=\frac{2\cdot0.510}{0.340}=3,

so the third harmonic is observed (f3=3v/2L=3⋅340/(2⋅0.510)=1000f_3=3v/2L=3\cdot340/(2\cdot0.510)=1000 Hz — the result agrees).

Transfer

Problem

Melde's experiment: a string of length L=1.50L=1.50 m between a vibrator and a pulley has linear density μ=2.0\mu=2.0 g/m. The vibrator runs at f=120f=120 Hz. Find the tension TT at which exactly n=4n=4 loops fit on the string, and give the coordinates of the nodes and antinodes.

Solution

Each loop equals λ/2\lambda/2, so from L=nλ/2L=n\lambda/2:

λ=2Ln=2⋅1.504=0.750 m.\lambda=\frac{2L}{n}=\frac{2\cdot1.50}{4}=0.750\ \text{m}.

The wave speed on the string:

v=fλ=120⋅0.750=90 m/s.v=f\lambda=120\cdot0.750=90\ \text{m/s}.

From v=T/μv=\sqrt{T/\mu} we find the tension:

T=μv2=(2.0⋅10−3)⋅902=16.2 N.T=\mu v^2=(2.0\cdot10^{-3})\cdot90^2=16.2\ \text{N}.

Nodes are spaced λ/2=0.375\lambda/2=0.375 m apart, including the fixed ends: x=0x=0, 0.3750.375, 0.7500.750, 1.1251.125, 1.5001.500 m. Antinodes lie midway between them: x=0.1875x=0.1875, 0.56250.5625, 0.93750.9375, 1.31251.3125 m. If the tension changes, the speed and the number of loops change, which is why the experiment serves as a measurement of TT or μ\mu.

Practice

Text

This practice runs in a simulation rather than with a real high-voltage vibrator, so it is safe.

  1. Open PhET Wave on a String and choose Oscillate mode with a Fixed End.
  2. Set the amplitude to 0.50.5 cm and the frequency to 1.51.5 Hz, then turn on Slow Motion and Show Rulers.
  3. Pause the simulation at a moment of maximum displacement and record the coordinates of the motionless points (nodes) and the points of largest swing (antinodes).
  4. Repeat for frequencies 1.01.0, 2.02.0 and 2.52.5 Hz and fill in a table: ff, number of loops nn, λ=2L/n\lambda=2L/n, v=fλv=f\lambda.
  5. Compare the speed you obtain with the value set in the simulation and with the formula v=fλv=f\lambda; explain why the nodes stay still even though the waves travel.
  6. As a check, note that the distance between neighbouring nodes is always λ/2\lambda/2 — measure it with the ruler and compare with the calculation.

Visual reference

Purpose

Show how adding two counter-propagating travelling waves produces motionless nodes and oscillating antinodes, and relate the node spacing to the wavelength.

Representation

A three-panel diagram on a common xx-axis.

  • Top panel: the wave y1=Asin⁡(kx−ωt)y_1=A\sin(kx-\omega t) travelling to the right (arrow).
  • Middle panel: the wave y2=Asin⁡(kx+ωt)y_2=A\sin(kx+\omega t) travelling to the left (arrow).
  • Bottom panel: their sum y=2Asin⁡(kx)cos⁡(ωt)y=2A\sin(kx)\cos(\omega t) at the instant of maximum swing; nodes are marked with dots N and joined by a dashed line, antinodes are marked A, and arrows show the spacing λ/2\lambda/2 between neighbouring nodes.

The graph also shows the envelope 2A∣sin⁡(kx)∣2A|\sin(kx)| as thin dotted lines.

Real-world examples

Standing wave on a gym rope

Scenario

In a school gym a rope of length L=4.0 mL = 4.0\,\text{m} is fixed at both ends and shaken at f=2.5 Hzf = 2.5\,\text{Hz}. The rope settles into a pattern with n=2n = 2 stationary loops: three places do not move at all (x=0x = 0, x=2.0 mx = 2.0\,\text{m}, x=4.0 mx = 4.0\,\text{m}), and two places swing with the largest amplitude ±0.30 m\pm 0.30\,\text{m}. For this mode λ=2L/n=4.0 m\lambda = 2L/n = 4.0\,\text{m}, so the wave speed along the rope is v=fλ=2.5×4.0=10 m/sv = f\lambda = 2.5 \times 4.0 = 10\,\text{m/s}.

Connection

Each loop is the sum of the wave travelling to the right and the wave reflected from the fixed end. At the three node positions the two displacements are always equal in magnitude and opposite in sign, so their sum is zero at every instant — that is the definition of a node. Halfway between neighbouring nodes the two waves are in phase, so the amplitude doubles to 2A2A; the whole-number-of-half-wavelengths condition L=nλ/2L = n\lambda/2, i.e. λn=2L/n\lambda_n = 2L/n, selects the frequencies that build a steady pattern instead of a travelling wave.

Standing waves inside a microwave oven

Scenario

A microwave oven drives its cavity at f=2.45 GHzf = 2.45\,\text{GHz}. With c=3.00×108 m/sc = 3.00\times10^{8}\,\text{m/s} the wavelength in air is λ=cf=3.00×1082.45×109=0.122 m≈12.2 cm.\lambda = \frac{c}{f} = \frac{3.00\times10^{8}}{2.45\times10^{9}} = 0.122\,\text{m} \approx 12.2\,\text{cm}. The metal walls reflect the wave, so the electric field forms a standing pattern; the zones that heat food most strongly (electric-field antinodes) are separated by λ/2≈6.1 cm\lambda/2 \approx 6.1\,\text{cm}. Across a 25 cm25\,\text{cm} wide cavity that is about 25/6.1≈425/6.1 \approx 4 hot bands, which is why the turntable keeps food from sitting in a cold band.

Connection

Two identical waves travelling in opposite directions are added here: one launched by the magnetron, one reflected by the metal wall. The sum at a point fixed in space oscillates with a constant amplitude 2Acos⁡(2πx/λ)2A\cos(2\pi x/\lambda) — zero right at the wall (a node: E=0E = 0 on a conductor surface) and maximum at a distance λ/2\lambda/2 from it. The turntable averages the heating over many positions of the food, so the node/antinode map is the main reason an oven is fitted with a rotating plate.

Noise-cancelling headphones

Scenario

Noise-cancelling headphones listen to the ambient sound and emit a mirror copy of it. Suppose a fan hums at f=150 Hzf = 150\,\text{Hz} with sound-pressure amplitude 0.20 Pa0.20\,\text{Pa}. In air at 20∘C20^{\circ}\text{C} (v=343 m/sv = 343\,\text{m/s}) the wavelength is λ=v/f=343/150=2.29 m\lambda = v/f = 343/150 = 2.29\,\text{m}, and one period lasts T=1/f=6.7 msT = 1/f = 6.7\,\text{ms}. To cancel the hum the headphone signal must be delayed by half a period, Δt=T/2=3.3 ms\Delta t = T/2 = 3.3\,\text{ms}, which corresponds to a phase shift Δφ=π\Delta\varphi = \pi.

Connection

This is superposition in time rather than in space: at the eardrum the two pressure waves add algebraically. With equal amplitudes and Δφ=π\Delta\varphi = \pi the resultant pressure is 0 Pa0\,\text{Pa} (complete destructive interference), whereas with Δφ=0\Delta\varphi = 0 it would be 0.40 Pa0.40\,\text{Pa}. Real headphones reach 1010–20 dB20\,\text{dB} of reduction because amplitude matching and the half-period delay are only approximate.